ROI vs Hit Rate What Should You Really Focus On

ROI vs Hit Rate: What Should You Really Focus On?

by

When evaluating your performance as a bettor, what’s the most important metric to focus on?

Some will say Hit Rate (your win percentage), others swear by ROI (Return on Investment). The truth? Both matter—but one is far more important for long-term success.

In this article, we’ll break down the key differences between hit rate and ROI, show why ROI is often misunderstood, and explain how you can use both metrics together to become a sharper, more profitable bettor.

ROI vs Hit Rate: What Should You Really Focus On?

What Is Hit Rate?

Your hit rate (also called win rate or strike rate) is the percentage of bets you win out of the total placed.

Formula:
Hit Rate (%) = (Number of Winning Bets / Total Bets) × 100

Example:

  • 100 bets placed

  • 58 bets won

  • Your hit rate = 58%

It’s a straightforward stat that tells you how often you’re getting things “right”—but it doesn’t tell you if you’re making money.

What Is ROI?

ROI stands for Return on Investment. It tells you how much profit (or loss) you’re generating compared to the amount staked.

Formula:
ROI (%) = [(Total Profit – Total Stake) / Total Stake] × 100

Example:

  • Total staked: €1,000

  • Total return: €1,080

  • ROI = [(1,080 – 1,000) / 1,000] × 100 = +8%

ROI is about efficiency, not frequency. It’s the key metric that professional bettors use to measure performance.

High Hit Rate Doesn’t Mean Profit

Let’s say Bettor A has a hit rate of 70%. Sounds impressive, right?

But if they’re betting on short odds (like 1.10) and losing the few big ones, their ROI might be negative.

Meanwhile, Bettor B has a hit rate of only 40%, but they bet on odds of 3.00 and win just enough to maintain a +15% ROI.

Who’s the better bettor?
Answer: Bettor B, every time.

Because it’s not how often you win that matters. It’s how much you win when you do—and how much you lose when you don’t.

ROI vs Hit Rate in Different Betting Styles

Betting Style Expected Hit Rate Expected ROI
Favorites (low odds) High (60–75%) Low or negative
Underdogs Low (20–40%) High (if sharp)
Value betting Moderate (40–55%) Moderate to high
Arbitrage/Surebets 100% Tiny but positive

As you can see, there’s no “ideal” hit rate. It all depends on your strategy.

In fact, professional tipsters often have hit rates under 50%—but positive ROI over the long term.

Why Bettors Obsess Over Hit Rate (and Why That’s Dangerous)

It’s easy to fall into the trap of chasing a high win rate:

  • It feels good to win often

  • It looks better on paper

  • It feeds short-term confidence

But if your ROI is negative, you’re simply winning often but losing money.

A bettor who wins 7 out of 10 bets at odds of 1.10 will still lose in the long run if one underdog hits.

High hit rate ≠ profitable

Why ROI Is King

Here’s why ROI is the gold standard of performance metrics:

  • Takes stake size into account

  • Accounts for both wins and losses

  • Works across all bet types and odds

  • Reflects true profit generation over time

  • Cannot be manipulated by selective data

When you track your ROI consistently, you learn:

  • Which strategies are working

  • Which bet types you should avoid

  • Where you’re making or losing money

How to Track Hit Rate and ROI Effectively

You can use Excel or Google Sheets with formulas like:

=COUNTIF(ResultRange, "WIN") / COUNTA(ResultRange) (for hit rate)
=(SUM(ProfitRange) / SUM(StakeRange)) * 100 (for ROI)
Or… let BetProfitLab do the heavy lifting:

  • Hit rate and ROI auto-calculated

  • Viewable per bet type, sport, date, or period

  • Graphs and dashboards included

  • Exportable data for analysis

Which Metric Should You Focus On?

The answer is: both—but with priority on ROI.

Use hit rate to:

  • Understand how often you’re winning

  • Monitor consistency in short runs

  • Compare performance across similar bet types

Use ROI to:

  • Measure real profitability

  • Compare different strategies

  • Guide decisions on stake sizing and bet selection

Don’t Let Ego Fool You

Many bettors chase high win rates to feed their ego. But the smartest bettors chase one thing only: profit.

They’re not afraid of losing 6 out of 10 bets… as long as they’re making money in the end.

ROI vs Hit Rate: What Should You Really Focus On?

In the long run, ROI is what separates profitable bettors from lucky ones.

Track your hit rate, sure. But make ROI your north star.

If you’re serious about improving your betting performance, make sure you’re tracking both metrics—and interpreting them the right way.

With BetProfitLab, you can automate this entire process and make better decisions based on real data, not guesswork.